2025: Bronx Voted Sea Shore Restaurant Best Margarita!
Sea Shore Restaurant
591 City Island Avenue
(718) 885-0300 – seashorerestaurant.com
Nothing says island vibes quite like a perfectly crafted margarita, and it’s no surprise that Sea Shore Restaurant earned recognition as a 2025 Winner in the Margarita category. Known for its laid-back waterfront charm, this City Island favorite serves margaritas that strike the ideal balance of tangy, smooth, and refreshing. Each glass is mixed with top-shelf ingredients and a hint of coastal flair, making it the perfect complement to their fresh seafood offerings. Guests can sip their drinks while soaking in scenic views of the water, adding to the restaurant’s signature blend of flavor and atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where every margarita feels like a celebration by the sea.
2024: Bronx Voted Estrellita Poblana Best Margarita!
Estrellita Poblana
2231 Westchester Ave
(718) 518-7425 – estrellitapoblana.nyc
Estrellita Poblana has the most refreshing margaritas in the Bronx. While they certainly pride themselves on having some of the best Mexican cocktails in all of New York City, it is Estrellita Poblana’s margaritas that really pack a good punch. Established in 1999, Estrellita Poblana takes great quality in the service they provide. Their food and drinks are created using the highest quality and freshest ingredients. The staff on hand are always friendly and personable, with their mission being to make you feel at home. Estrellita Poblana is sure to provide you with the delicious meals and drinks at quality prices. Tradition and taste are combined at this Bronx location. When you do pay them a visit, be sure to order a margarita.
2023: Bronx Voted Cocina Chente Best Margarita!
Cocina Chente
3535 Riverdale Ave
(347) 843-8081 – cocinachente.com
Cocina Chente stands as the undisputed purveyor of the Bronx’s finest margaritas, transforming the classic cocktail into an art form. Their traditional margarita, a flawless blend of Tequila, Triple Sec, and fresh lime juice, sets the standard for excellence. Elevating the experience further, the Mezcalita, crafted with Mezcal, Lime Juice, and Agave with a spicy salt rim, adds a smoky twist, while the Chenterita, a fusion of Mezcal, Tequila blanco, Grapefruit Juice, Lime Juice, and Pink Peppercorn Syrup with a spicy salt rim, unveils a symphony of flavors. Cocina Chente’s margaritas redefine the Bronx’s libation landscape, making it the ultimate destination for connoisseurs.
2022: Bronx Voted Taqueria Tlaxcalli Best Margarita!
Taqueria Tlaxcalli
2103 Starling Ave
(347) 851-3085 – taqueriatlaxcalli.com
It’s margarita time! If you want to find the best margarita that the Bronx has to offer, your first stop needs to be Taqueria Tlaxcalli. Whether you like a classic margarita or want something with more of a spicy kick, Taqueria Tlaxcalli has been the top spot for those craving a margarita to go with their night out. Their margaritas will have you wasted away in Margaritaville (for our Jimmy Buffett fans out there) in no time. Plus, their margarita pairs perfectly with the restaurant’s menu of delicious Mexican fare. Don’t forget to try out a spicy rim to complete the experience!