Welcome to your guide to the best Italian restaurants in the Bronx, where locals celebrate their favorite spots for classic Italian cuisine. From mouthwatering pasta dishes to authentic wood-fired pizzas, the Bronx is home to a vibrant culinary scene that blends tradition with innovation. Each year, New Yorkers cast their votes to determine which establishments truly stand out. Whether you’re a lifelong Bronxite or just visiting, our list of winners showcases the finest Italian dining experiences in the borough. Ready to savor the flavors of Italy right here in the Bronx? Let’s explore the top-rated Italian restaurants as chosen by the community!
2024: Bronx Voted Artie’s Steak & Seafood Best Italian Restaurant!
Artie’s Steak & Seafood
394 City Island Ave
(719) 885-9885 – artiescityisland.com
There are many Italians in the Bronx and they definitely know their high-quality cuisine. Artie’s has been a favorite of locals and visitors for many years and has earned its lofty reputation with delicious food and a casual, classic Italian feel. Customers experience a friendly crowd and, hopefully, take advantage of Artie’s famous jumbo martinis. And what would an authentic Italian meal be without a pairing with a fine wine? Whether sipping a pre-dinner Pinot Grigio at one of Artie’s cozy corner tables or enjoying a Chianti in the relaxing cocktail lounge, customers are delighted by the expansive wine offering.
2023: Bronx Voted Artie’s Steak & Seafood Best Italian Restaurant!
Artie’s Steak & Seafood
394 City Island Ave
(719) 885-9885 – artiescityisland.com
Artie’s Steak & Seafood is a culinary gem that marries classic elegance with a warm, inviting ambiance. The restaurant boasts a menu that reflects a commitment to excellence, featuring premium steaks, fresh seafood, and Italian-inspired delicacies. With a nod to tradition and a flair for innovation, Artie’s chefs craft dishes that are a delight to the taste buds. The restaurant’s timeless charm extends beyond the plate, enveloping patrons in a welcoming, cozy atmosphere with tasteful decor. Artie’s Steak and Seafood isn’t just a dining experience; it’s a celebration of flavors, a gathering place for family and friends to savor exceptional cuisine.
2022: The Bronx Voted IceHouse Cafe Best Italian Restaurant!
IceHouse Cafe
140 Reynolds Ave
(718) 863-5580 – instagram.com/icehousecafebx?igshid=wds9u5ig62m2
Family-owned and operated, IceHouse Cafe is located in the Hammonds Cove Marina, and has a spectacular overlook view of the Throggs Neck bridge. Offering a variety of dishes from seafood, Italian pasta, and American-style food, some reviewers have called IceHouse Cafe a hidden gem nestled in an area that’s down the road from SUNY Maritime Academy. But the culinary world knows how good IceHouse Cafe is, as the restaurant racked up high marks in the 2022 Best of the Bronx contest for its American and Italian cuisines, as well as its family-style and scenic setting. They are also a three-time champion for best wings at Maritime College and Best Wings In the Bronx by The New York Daily News.