2025: Bronx Voted Sammy’s Fish Box Best Hot Dogs!
Sammy’s Fish Box
41 City Island Avenue
(718) 885-0920 – sammysfishbox.com
Known for its iconic seafood, Sammy’s Fish Box also takes home the 2025 Winner award in the Hot Dogs category, proving that its culinary mastery extends beyond the sea. This beloved City Island restaurant has built a reputation for hearty, flavor-packed dishes, and its take on the classic hot dog is no exception. Grilled to perfection and served with that unmistakable Sammy’s flair, it offers a satisfying bite that pairs perfectly with the restaurant’s coastal ambiance. From family outings to casual lunches by the water, every visit delivers both comfort and quality. With decades of excellence and a loyal following, it’s no surprise this Bronx institution continues to earn praise for its unforgettable menu offerings.
2024: Bronx Voted Nathan’s Famous Best Hot Dogs!
Nathan’s Famous
200 Baychester Ave
(718) 671-1234 – nathansfamous.com
Nathan’s Famous says it all when it comes to hot dogs, aka frankfurters, and remains number one in the Bronx. This iconic hot dog chain is known for their “world famous frankfurters since 1916.” It all began when a small hot dog stand opened on Coney Island in Brooklyn and these delicious frankfurters became known all around. Today Nathan’s Famous is still synonymous with their delicious all-beef franks, deep-fried and then topped with favorite classics like mustard and sauerkraut or more innovative options like chopped onions and jalapeños. Whether enjoyed plain or loaded up, Nathan’s hot dogs are a beloved treat, but no need to go to Coney Island when you can grab one right on Baychester Avenue.
2023: Bronx Voted Nathan’s Famous Best Hot Dogs!
Nathan’s Famous
200 Baychester Ave
(718) 671-1234 – nathansfamous.com
Nathan’s Famous indisputably claims the throne for the Bronx’s finest hot dogs, embodying a legacy of culinary excellence that spans generations. These iconic franks are a quintessential New York experience, renowned for their juicy, flavorful bite that captures the essence of the city. Crafted with premium ingredients and a time-tested recipe, Nathan’s hot dogs are a celebration of American gastronomic history. The perfect snap of the casing and the savory burst of each bite make every visit to Nathan’s an immersive journey into the heart of hot dog perfection in the Bronx.
2022: Bronx Voted The Original Hot Dog Factory Best Hot Dogs!
The Original Hot Dog Factory
3398 E Tremont Ave
(718) 450-8995 – theoriginalhotdogfactory.com
If you’re in the Bronx and want a hot dog, why not head on over to the place that readers say serves up the best hot dog in the borough? That would be The Original Hot Dog Factory. One of several locations across the country, the shop on East Tremont Avenue in the Bronx serves up a wide range of hot dog options, including popular favorites such as the Boston Dog (a steamed beef hot dog topped with baked beans, bacon bits and chopped onions) and the Bratwurst Dog (a deep fried bratwurst topped with sauerkraut and grilled onions). Other hot dogs that customers love here include the Jamaican Jerk Chicken Dog (a seasoned chicken dog topped with grilled pineapples, chopped onions and sweet island sauce). One glowing online reviewer calls the food here “delicious,” noting the “hot dogs were beautifully made” and his son and niece “keep bugging me to come back.”